Dining Guide
Note: Travel Directions are posted from the Inn to the restaurants. If you will be traveling to a restaurant from a differant starting point, replace the Inn address located in field "A" with your new starting address.
Mr. Willy’s Rte 42 Monticello 12701 - 794 0888. Open Tuesday-Saturday. 3.9 miles from the Inn. www.mrwillys.com/ Travel Directions
Buona Fortuna, 46 Forestburgh Rd Monticello 12701. - 796 4110 Open 7 days, 4-10 pm. 4.2 miles from the Inn. www.buonafortunany.com/ Travel Directions
Monticello Raceway/Racino Rte 17B Monticello 12701 - 794 4100 6.0 miles from the Inn www.monticellocasinoandraceway.com/dining.php Travel Directions
Brother Bruno's, 4050 Rte 42 North, Monticello 12701 - 791 4600. Open 7 days. 7.1 miles from the Inn. www.freedomtaxcenters.com/brotherbruno Directions
The Blue Horizon Diner, Rte 42N Monticello 12701 - 796 2210. Open 7 days. 7.1 miles from the Inn. A comfortable traditional Greek diner. Travel Directions
The Wet Noodle 42 Kitz Rd, Monticello (just off Rte 17B) – 794 4800. Open 7 days for lunch and dinner. 9.8 miles from the Inn. Not much ambiance, but the food is delicious. http://wetnoodlepizza.com/ Travel Directions
The Front Porch, 1577 Rte 17B, White Lake 12786 - 583 4838. Open Wednesday-Saturday for dinner; Sunday 10-1:30 13 miles from the Inn http://www.thefrontporch.us/ Travel Directions
Luzon Station, 3 Horseshoe Lake Rd, Kauneonga Lake 12749 – 583-4200. Open Wednesday-Saturday, 4-10. 13.5 miles from the Inn. http://www.luzonstation.com/ Travel Directions
Benji & Jake’s, 5 Horseshoe Lake Rd, Kauneonga Lake 12749 – 583 4031. Open Friday–Sunday. 13.5 miles from the Inn. Dog friendly on deck. http://www.benjiandjakes.com/Benji_%26_Jakes/Welcome.html Travel Directions
Lakeside 55 – 3575 State Rte 55 – Kauneonga Lake 12749 - 583-4400. Open 7 days. 13.5 Miles from Inn. Lakeside55.com. Travel Directions
Piccolo Paese, 5 Rte 52, Liberty 12754 - 292 7210. Closed Monday. 14 miles from the Inn. Travel Directions
We have eaten here several times and it seems the food is always terrific. If you are looking for the normal run of the mill Italian dishes, you are in the wrong place. All the dishes are unique in some way and the ingredients are always exceptionally fresh .Service is outstanding and as I said, the food is outstanding. This place is a little pricey, but it is worth every penny.
Eldred Preserve, 1050 Rte 55, Eldred 12732 - 557 8316. 15 Miles from the Inn. Seafood and Continental cuisine. Their specialty is fresh trout, served many different ways. Open Wednesday-Sunday. http://www.eldredpreserve.com/menu2011.htm Travel Directions
The Old Homestead Restaurant, Bridgeville Rd, Monticello 12701 - 794 8973. 15.7 miles from Inn. Open Wednesday-Sunday. http://www.theoldhomesteadny.com/ Travel Directions
Dancing Cat Saloon & Distillery 2037 Route 17B, Bethel, NY 12720 583-3141. 15.8 miles from Inn Open Tuesday-Sunday. dancingcatsaloon.com Travel Directions
Tre Alberi - Rte 97 – Barryville 12719 - 557 6104 21 miles from the Inn. Closed Wednesday. Travel Directions
Customer review: This place is incredible! Happened upon it by chance and decided to try it. This is real deal Northern Italian direct from the old world with white tablecloths and cotton napkins and not pizzeria food. Real food. The owners are a husband and wife who somehow work together to pull it off.
Aroma Thyme Bistro – 165 Canal St – Ellenville 12428 – 647 3000. 21 miles from Inn Closed Wednesday. http://www.aromathymebistro.com/ Travel Directions
The 1906 Restaurant - Main Street – Callicoon 12723 - 887 1906. Open 7 days. 27.8 miles from Inn http://www.1906 restaurant.com/ Travel Directions
Matthew’s on Main St, 19 Lower Main St, Callicoon 12723 - 887 5636. Open 7 days. 27 Miles from Inn. http://www.matthewsonmain.com/ Travel Directions
Gerard’s River Grill, 15 Main St, Narrowsburg 12764 - 252 6562. Open Tuesday-Sunday for lunch & dinner. 28 miles from Inn. Travel Directions Customer review: Gerard cooks all the food in this restaurant and he is an extremely talented chef. I had a grilled salmon that almost melted in my mouth. My partner had Linguine con Vongole and the sauce was so incredible we both sopped up every drop with bread. We had the grilled vegtable with mozzarella for appetizer and it was delectable. The white wine selection is good, but limited. The reds are plentiful. A truly great meal.